Fringe 2023: Pleasance Comedy Reserve

Rating: 3.5 out of 5.

The Pleasance Comedy Reserve has been running for 17 years, and hand picks and supports new acts to come to the Fringe. It helped launch the careers of comics such as Joe Lycett, Sophie Duker and Lou Sanders. This year, Pleasance are running two of these shows, one at the Dome and one at the Courtyard, giving more comedians the chance to access the Fringe. This review is for the Pleasance Comedy Reserve at the Dome, which features Kyrah Gray, Jin Hao Li, Will Robbins and Abby Wambaugh. The comedians take it in turn every show to host or perform, giving them a chance to try each part.

The issues with a show such as this is that not every comedian will appeal to every person. As each set is only 15 minutes, the Comedy Reserve provides a good way to try out some new comedians without having to suffer through an hour-long set. However this also means your favourite comedian of the four may come on first, leaving you feeling somewhat flat for the rest of the show. 

The other minor issues with a structure such as this is that the same audience members get picked on for crowd work. I’m not sure if the comedians are advised to do more crowd work than normal but I noticed far more audience interaction than I’ve seen in other shows. This can sometimes fall a bit flat or just feel awkward.

My personal favourite of the four comedians was Kyrah Gray, who seemed the most comfortable and natural on stage. She has a natural vibrancy that was backed up with some great material discussing a real variety of subjects, including her experience dating outside her comfort zone, when she dated a white English man. The build up and pay off of her stories is always worth it. 

The other three comics were something of a mixed bag. As is often the case with stand up, some jokes landed far better than others, and some I just really didn’t enjoy listening to, but despite this they all still have one or two really insightful and well written gags.

All in all, The Pleasance Comedy Reserve is a fun and easy way to discover some new and up-and-coming acts. Just don’t expect it to be the funniest show you see this Fringe.

The Pleasance Comedy Reserve at the Dome is at the Pleasance Dome at 9.40pm until 28 August (not 15, 22). Tickets are available here.

Image by the reviewer.