Another meeting, another game where the curse fails to be broken, as Scotland lost their Nations Championship match against New Zealand on 7 November. While the final score of 21-43 was a disappointment for the home fans, especially after a good fight in the first half made many hopeful that there was a chance at defeating the All Blacks after 120 years, the team now needs to look forward to the rest of the tournament. Winning will now be vital for the rest of their campaign, as this loss means that Scotland have slipped down to fourth in the Northern Hemisphere rankings, now trailing four points behind England and Ireland, and sixth overall. The question on everyone’s lips: how can Scotland bounce back from a defeat like this?
One of the biggest issues at the moment seems to be defence. Scotland has given away too many opportunities to their rivals, which has resulted in conceding 21 tries in total in the tournament so far. While Scotland’s victory over Argentina was a proud moment in the first round of the competition, it highlighted the problem early on: five tries were still yielded to the South American team.
In the fixture against South Africa in the following round, the Springboks ran away with the win, landing six tries to secure a 42-28 victory, and in this latest match the All Blacks scored seven tries against Scotland across both halves. Strategic changes, as well as greater unity within the defensive line, seems to be the clear solution, as relying on the team’s strong offensive playing alone does not guarantee victory when up against a squad that equals them in that area. Fans will now be looking to defence coach Lee Radford, who joined the team in 2025, to resolve this issue, but with the next fixtures looming just around the corner, the challenge will be how quickly they can make a turnaround.
Penalties are another problem that appear to plague the team, with many of them borne out of preventable mistakes. Holding on or scrum penalties are of recent note – not the sort of blunders that can be afforded when up against some of the best players in the world. Racking up otherwise avoidable errors hands the opposition advantages and could cost the team dearly. It begs the question as to whether this is a result of crumbling under pressure or a lack of discipline in Scotland’s playing.
Could a lesson be learned from the All Blacks themselves? There is a reason why the team has the reputation they do. When the New Zealand squad plays, their performance and teamwork feels cohesive, which translates into incredible winning streaks, such as the one we are seeing in this tournament. There are some loose ends with the coordination between the Scotland players that could benefit from being revised, which would in turn aid the other issues that the team are facing.
The upcoming matches against Australia and Japan will provide Scotland the chance to right the mistakes from these first four rounds. Victories against these teams will be crucial if the squad want to climb back up the table, but the point deficit will also play an important role in how they stack up against England and Ireland. Both of the Southern Hemisphere teams have been on the weaker side, both losing three out of their four respective games played so far, and Scotland appears to be stronger overall.
However, this does not mean that they will go down easily. If the boys in blue cannot remedy their defence, then once again we will see otherwise avoidable tries slip away to the opposition. Gregor Townsend and the rest of the coaching team will have a lot of expectation on them to turn the trajectory of the team around and deliver results, but whether they can achieve this in a short window is to be seen.
“Uruguay vs Scotland rugby match in 2024 – 62” by NaBUru38 is licensed under CC BY-SA 4.0.






