Fringe 2025: If You Don’t Laugh

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Performed by the Mermaids of the Fringe, If You Don’t Laugh is a student production from the University of St Andrews. The gender-bent dark comedy is a refreshing outlook on the complexities of coping with the loss of a friend. 

The play takes on a structure that parallels the five stages of grief — denial, anger,  bargaining, depression, and acceptance — where the characters Carl and Buzz must  confront the many faces of grief to the loss of their comatose friend.  

Among the interesting staging decisions made by this production is the choice for the  audience to play the role of their comatose mate in the hospital ward, with Carl and Buzz  speaking directly to the audience. With every visit, the friends bring milk trays, flowers  and stories of their rambunctious past few days to keep their friend in the loop.  

Though a barren set and minimal costuming, the actresses create a transformative  atmosphere through their use of comedic timing and physical comedy. It is impressive  how much this production achieves solely through collaborative imagination.  

With bits like objectifying the sexy nurse, doing the worm in the club, and having a fight  with the car pulled up next to them, we can’t help but eventually fall for the  unconventional warmth of Carl and Buzz as we root for their successes in this story of  friendship, love and loss.  

Through this brief encounter with Carl, Buzz, and Syd we are prompted to consider how loss is experienced. In this comedy, grief is ever-changing. It is the wishful hoping of a  friend waking up, and it is the anger that accompanies the realisation he may not. This  play commands such emotional connection to its characters that we continue wishing the best for Carl and Buzz even once the play ends.

Image courtesy of Mermaids of the Fringe, provided to The Student to use as press material.