Scottish prisons have reached a record high number of inmates, passing the previous record of 8,420 set in 2012. This is over 600 inmates higher than the capacity of 7,805. Scotland currently has one of the highest imprisonment rates in Western Europe. The Scottish Prison Service (SPS) stated this is a big concern for keeping inmates safe, and action from the Scottish government is vital in order to ensure safety for those who live and work in prisons. Despite the urgency for space for those who do commit serious crimes, it is necessary for prison environments to operate effectively, to reduce reoffending – which is becoming increasingly difficult with the soaring numbers of inmates currently exceeding capacities of prisons in Scotland.
There has been an increase of 700 long-term prisoners from 2020, which equates to a centre the size of HMP Addiewell, located between Glasgow and Edinburgh. The SPS has confirmed that the increase in inmates is due to the number of people involved in Serious Organised Crime Groups and sexual offences. One officer complaint concluded that there are many inmates with serious mental health issues that “should be nowhere near a prison environment.”
So what does this tell us about the type of crimes being sentenced? According to the Scottish Government website, crimes of dishonesty are the highest percentage of recorded crimes, at 37 per cent of all crimes between 2024 and 2025. The lowest is sexual crimes, at only 5 per cent of recorded crimes. Are prisons in Scotland working effectively to attempt to rehabilitate inmates, or is prison merely a service of time until inmates are released?
As of 2021-2022, statistics show that 27 per cent of prisoners were reconvicted within 12 months of release, which had been increasing yearly by one per cent. If this was the statistic in 2022, then with the overflowing of inmates currently, this is likely increasing. Additionally, the amount of data surrounding the mental health issues faced in Scottish prisons is scarce, with “no robust figures of the prevalence of mental health needs for inmates in Scotland.” This makes it difficult to identify specific needs for rehabilitation and deterrence for inmates, increasing the number of re-convictions if inmates are not receiving productive mental health services whilst serving time.
This lack of information can say a lot about how Scotland’s prisons approach rehabilitation, and the rate of re-conviction within a year of release can suggest that the time served in prison is not productive for those serving shorter sentences for lower crimes. Attempts for rehabilitation can be very subjective and should be judged by the cases and crimes of individual inmates, particularly for first-time offenders.
In order for prisons to work effectively, they must not be overflowing capacity, and it is essential that there is space for those who commit severe crimes and require long-term sentences, such as sex offenders.
“Addiewell Prison – geograph.org.uk – 3517149” by M J Richardson is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.
Like this:
Like Loading...
Related
More Inmates than Space: The Mishandling of Scotland’s Prison System
Scottish prisons have reached a record high number of inmates, passing the previous record of 8,420 set in 2012. This is over 600 inmates higher than the capacity of 7,805. Scotland currently has one of the highest imprisonment rates in Western Europe. The Scottish Prison Service (SPS) stated this is a big concern for keeping inmates safe, and action from the Scottish government is vital in order to ensure safety for those who live and work in prisons. Despite the urgency for space for those who do commit serious crimes, it is necessary for prison environments to operate effectively, to reduce reoffending – which is becoming increasingly difficult with the soaring numbers of inmates currently exceeding capacities of prisons in Scotland.
There has been an increase of 700 long-term prisoners from 2020, which equates to a centre the size of HMP Addiewell, located between Glasgow and Edinburgh. The SPS has confirmed that the increase in inmates is due to the number of people involved in Serious Organised Crime Groups and sexual offences. One officer complaint concluded that there are many inmates with serious mental health issues that “should be nowhere near a prison environment.”
So what does this tell us about the type of crimes being sentenced? According to the Scottish Government website, crimes of dishonesty are the highest percentage of recorded crimes, at 37 per cent of all crimes between 2024 and 2025. The lowest is sexual crimes, at only 5 per cent of recorded crimes. Are prisons in Scotland working effectively to attempt to rehabilitate inmates, or is prison merely a service of time until inmates are released?
As of 2021-2022, statistics show that 27 per cent of prisoners were reconvicted within 12 months of release, which had been increasing yearly by one per cent. If this was the statistic in 2022, then with the overflowing of inmates currently, this is likely increasing. Additionally, the amount of data surrounding the mental health issues faced in Scottish prisons is scarce, with “no robust figures of the prevalence of mental health needs for inmates in Scotland.” This makes it difficult to identify specific needs for rehabilitation and deterrence for inmates, increasing the number of re-convictions if inmates are not receiving productive mental health services whilst serving time.
This lack of information can say a lot about how Scotland’s prisons approach rehabilitation, and the rate of re-conviction within a year of release can suggest that the time served in prison is not productive for those serving shorter sentences for lower crimes. Attempts for rehabilitation can be very subjective and should be judged by the cases and crimes of individual inmates, particularly for first-time offenders.
In order for prisons to work effectively, they must not be overflowing capacity, and it is essential that there is space for those who commit severe crimes and require long-term sentences, such as sex offenders.
“Addiewell Prison – geograph.org.uk – 3517149” by M J Richardson is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.
Share this:
Like this:
Related