In December 2025 and January 2026, the Iranian government killed 7,000-35,000 of its own citizens during the largest protests against the regime that the country has seen in many years. The estimations of those killed vary so widely because of internet blackouts which make it hard to get reliable information out of the country. Even on the low end, this is a horrendous figure. Some would argue that this and the rest of Iran’s terrible human rights record give a humanitarian imperative to intervene in Iran’s regime.
Humanitarian reasons, however, have hardly been cited in the Trump administration’s various and contradicting justifications for the US-Israeli War on Iran. Donald Trump, Pete Hegseth, and Marco Rubio have varyingly cited that: Iran had almost developed a nuclear weapon; Israel was going to strike first which forced the US to join them; and Iran was about to strike and so the US pre-empted them. If this internal confusion within the Trump administration doesn’t make it clear enough, the rhetoric of various government outlets boasting that they are showing Iran “no mercy”, and the continuing strikes to densely populated areas and civilian infrastructure, prove this is not a war that is serious about humanitarian intervention.
Proponents of the war may cite Iran’s theocratic government as grounds enough for intervening but, when this argument comes from the mouths of the Trump and Netanyahu administrations, it collapses as soon as it’s examined.
Trump leads an openly Christian Nationalist administration that, particularly in his first term, gained power through outspoken Islamophobia. Netanyahu leads the most right-wing government in Israel’s history which has committed genocide in Gaza and is influenced by the extremist religious ideology of a Greater Israel in its expansions into the West Bank and Southern Lebanon (both of which have increased since the start of the war). Deriding a theocracy on grounds that it fosters oppression, inequality, and lack of accountability is one thing, but deriding one simply because it doesn’t follow your religious agenda rings more of medieval religious wars than of modern democratic politics.
The UK has not yet involved itself in the war beyond allowing the US to use UK military bases for defensive purposes, but its continued support of the US and Israel implicitly condones their operations. Furthermore, there is also hypocrisy in the UK criticising theocratic governments. The UK, along with Iran and the Vatican City, is one of only three countries in the world where government positions are explicitly reserved for religious leaders of the state religion: 26 seats in the House of Lords are reserved for the highest-ranking bishops of the Church of England. Not to mention that we are still ruled by a hereditary monarch who is simultaneously the head of the Church and whose position is, in theory, legitimised by God.
While the Islamic Republic of Iran is clearly much more a theocracy than the US, Israel, the UK, or almost any other country in the world, I mention these hypocrisies to highlight the complicated influence of religion in many countries today and to show why the principle of separation of religion and state is so foundational to the modern democracy. If this is a principle that is important to them, the belligerents should perhaps focus instead on their domestic situation rather than embroiling themselves in a foreign war in which civilian casualties are climbing every day.
“Iran flag from Tabi’at bridge” by DavidSandoz is licensed under CC BY 2.0.
Related
The Hypocrisy in Criticisms of Iran’s Theocratic Government
In December 2025 and January 2026, the Iranian government killed 7,000-35,000 of its own citizens during the largest protests against the regime that the country has seen in many years. The estimations of those killed vary so widely because of internet blackouts which make it hard to get reliable information out of the country. Even on the low end, this is a horrendous figure. Some would argue that this and the rest of Iran’s terrible human rights record give a humanitarian imperative to intervene in Iran’s regime.
Humanitarian reasons, however, have hardly been cited in the Trump administration’s various and contradicting justifications for the US-Israeli War on Iran. Donald Trump, Pete Hegseth, and Marco Rubio have varyingly cited that: Iran had almost developed a nuclear weapon; Israel was going to strike first which forced the US to join them; and Iran was about to strike and so the US pre-empted them. If this internal confusion within the Trump administration doesn’t make it clear enough, the rhetoric of various government outlets boasting that they are showing Iran “no mercy”, and the continuing strikes to densely populated areas and civilian infrastructure, prove this is not a war that is serious about humanitarian intervention.
Proponents of the war may cite Iran’s theocratic government as grounds enough for intervening but, when this argument comes from the mouths of the Trump and Netanyahu administrations, it collapses as soon as it’s examined.
Trump leads an openly Christian Nationalist administration that, particularly in his first term, gained power through outspoken Islamophobia. Netanyahu leads the most right-wing government in Israel’s history which has committed genocide in Gaza and is influenced by the extremist religious ideology of a Greater Israel in its expansions into the West Bank and Southern Lebanon (both of which have increased since the start of the war). Deriding a theocracy on grounds that it fosters oppression, inequality, and lack of accountability is one thing, but deriding one simply because it doesn’t follow your religious agenda rings more of medieval religious wars than of modern democratic politics.
The UK has not yet involved itself in the war beyond allowing the US to use UK military bases for defensive purposes, but its continued support of the US and Israel implicitly condones their operations. Furthermore, there is also hypocrisy in the UK criticising theocratic governments. The UK, along with Iran and the Vatican City, is one of only three countries in the world where government positions are explicitly reserved for religious leaders of the state religion: 26 seats in the House of Lords are reserved for the highest-ranking bishops of the Church of England. Not to mention that we are still ruled by a hereditary monarch who is simultaneously the head of the Church and whose position is, in theory, legitimised by God.
A “true French experience”, but at what cost?
While the Islamic Republic of Iran is clearly much more a theocracy than the US, Israel, the UK, or almost any other country in the world, I mention these hypocrisies to highlight the complicated influence of religion in many countries today and to show why the principle of separation of religion and state is so foundational to the modern democracy. If this is a principle that is important to them, the belligerents should perhaps focus instead on their domestic situation rather than embroiling themselves in a foreign war in which civilian casualties are climbing every day.
“Iran flag from Tabi’at bridge” by DavidSandoz is licensed under CC BY 2.0.
Share this:
Like this:
Related