Album Review: Reality Awaits by The Strokes

Rating: 2 out of 5.

After 2020’s The New Abnormal saw them return to the popularity and quality of their breakthrough albums Room on Fire and the iconic Is This It, The Strokes return four years later with their seventh record: Reality Awaits. Their previous album — The New Abnormal — proved that even 20 years into their career, The Strokes were still capable of producing their best work yet. Reality Awaits is a considerably less convincing successor.

The problem isn’t that Reality Awaits lacks ideas. It features what is arguably frontman Julian Casablancas’ most adventurous vocal performance yet, backed by consistently impressive instrumentals from the rest of the band. The issue is that most of it is obscured by the album’s defining creative decision and central talking point: Casablancas’ borderline abusive use of autotune and vocal processing. On its own, this wouldn’t necessarily be a huge problem—Julian has long experimented with altering his voice in his work. In the band’s debut album — 2001’s Is This It — his vocals are heavily distorted and roughened. The problem is that this time it detracts from Casablanca’s actual vocal performance here, which is one of the album’s more interesting aspects.

Casablancas adopts a lounge-singer-esque swagger reminiscent of Alex Turner’s cadence on Arctic Monkeys’ Tranquillity Base Hotel & Casino. He is clearly aiming for something much more theatrical than his usual fare, evident in his swaggering vocals on ‘Going Shopping’, loosely veering from note-to-note, to his eccentric pseudo-English accent on ‘Dine N’ Dash’, his Mick Jagger affectations on ‘Fruits of Conquest’, and his Cohen-esque baritone speeches on “Falling Out of Love”. Casablancas croons, ad-libs, mutters and quips his way across the album, yet the autotune is incapable of reckoning with all these personalities. Julian’s stumbling, eccentric and spontaneous performance is hindered by production that amalgamates all these varied elements. Lounge croons, Jagger impressions and spoken-word quips are coated in an identical synthetic sheen. The result is something bizarrely self-sabotaging.

‘Falling Out of Love’ is the most obvious casualty. While lyrically sharp, Julian’s vocals are so aggressively processed that it detracts from any potential intimacy. With gentler, more nuanced vocal treatment, this could’ve been a genuinely affecting ballad. The production actively sabotages the song; what might have been vulnerable instead feels artificial, and the song is just a chore to sit through as a result.

Instrumentally, Reality Awaits is often very strong. Nick Valensi and Albert Hammond Jr.’s trademark interlocking guitars provide tracks like ‘Going to Babble On’, ‘Lonely in the Future’ and ‘Going Shopping’ with effortless grooves. ‘The Fruits of Conquest’ sees the New York rockers lean into The Rolling Stones, with a funky rhythm section featuring some lively hand percussion from drummer Fabrizio Moretti. These moments show a band still capable of sounding remarkably nimble more than two decades into their career.

However, these moments make the album’s failures more frustrating than ever. The songs are constantly forced to compete with Casablancas’ increasingly exhausting vocal histrionics. ‘Liar’s Remorse’ strips away most of the rhythm section, a potentially interesting choice that backfires massively as it leaves the overly processed vocals starkly vulnerable. Worse still, the song is just boring. Catchy hooks, dynamic instrumentation, and flashes of genuine inspiration are all left to struggle beneath this synthetic sludge. 

Casablancas has compared his embrace of autotune to Bob Dylan going electric, which — to put it mildly — is an ambitious comparison. The problem isn’t that The Strokes are experimenting. A seventh album simply recreating Is This It would arguably be more disappointing. No band survives this long by endlessly replicating its debut, and The Strokes aren’t twenty-something adults clawing their way through the NYC indie scene anymore. But experimentation isn’t automatically successful just because it is experimentation. Casablancas’ autotune isn’t just a weak aesthetic choice, it’s a betrayal of potentially much stronger material. Reality Awaits in its current state shows glimpses of an energetic and engaging album, but at times it is frankly irritating to listen to and frequently underwhelming.

Raph_PH, CC BY 2.0 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0, via Wikimedia Commons