Fringe 2023: Witches

Rating: 5 out of 5.

​Let’s put it out there: Witches is my highlight of the 2023 Fringe. The women-led production from the University of St Andrews is beautifully crafted, impeccably acted, and resonates deeply. The production is essentially a bottle episode, taking place entirely inside the living room of a girl’s flat as we follow Joan, her older sister Janet, and their mutual friend Isobel in preparation for a visit from the object of Joan’s affections. This simple premise unfurls into something much darker, and hurls towards a devastating conclusion. 

Creator Laura Walker and her co-director Isabella Cory, the co-founders of Turning Point Theatre Company, have a real dynamite of a script here. Their female characters are incredibly true to life; they could be typical students at Edinburgh (or St Andrews, or anywhere) and their flat decor reminds me of many a Marchmont abode. The writing balances realism with satire effortlessly and to great effect: these self-proclaimed feminists don’t know Alison Bechdel is a woman; their conversations probably don’t pass her eponymous Test; but then, how many of mine do? They poke fun at their characters when necessary while still reckoning with their anger and pain. 

​The crux of the show is a conversation between the younger sister Joan (Laura Bennie), making an argument for true love and non-toxic heterosexuality, against the jaded and embittered combination of Janet (Nell Lang) & Isobel (Nicole Sellew), who argue that sex is about ownership, and Joan will be inevitably disappointed by its result. Janet and Isobel are interesting young women, and I know many like them – I’ve even been them myself. They have sex with men who openly admit that they do not care about female pleasure, sex which the girls themselves don’t enjoy, yet continue to pursue regardless. ‘Why’, Joan asks, and the answer for Isobel and Janet seems to be: power. Ownership. Maybe violence.

​There’s a lot left unsaid here, which I found myself reflecting on for hours after Witches ended. As a historian of contemporary female violence, having just completed a masters thesis about the topic, I was left probing many questions. Why do we see female violence as empowering rather than emotionally devastating? What does it mean for violence to be justified? How might class, race or ethnicity complicate the power dynamics of female-male relationships? If the patriarchy benefits men, does it not certainly hurt them too, shackling them into boxes of acceptable behaviour and gender expression which make it impossible to express tenderness, sadness, or homosocial affection? What if we lived in a world where sex was less about power and more about joy? 

​There is so much to love about Witches, and its ability to prompt these questions is just one of them. Laura Bennie, Nell Lang, and Nicole Sellew are stars in the making and I would be unsurprised to see all three working professionally. Sellew engages with physical theatre in striking ways, using her limbs to convey so much of her character. Bennie’s understated and nuanced performance as Joan was deeply moving and hints at immense talent, leaving me tearful at times.

​About two thirds of the way through Witches, as it moved rapidly towards its inevitable climax, I became deeply worried that it would end in a celebratory fashion. This would have been the easier and less complicated choice. Thankfully, Cory and Walker opted against such an ending. They lean into the complexity, the devastation, and the pain of the show’s final moments. In doing so, they also leave room for many different interpretations and never attempt to tell the audience how we should feel about what we’ve just witnessed. I left feeling absolutely shattered in the best possible way. 

​Witches is an absolutely incredible feat, one that would be equally at home on the West End as in a tiny blackbox theatre off South Bridge. Take advantage of its pricing and intimate setting while you can, because all of the incredible women involved in its production are immense talents. I feel lucky to have seen their early work. 

​Witches runs daily at 12:40 at Greenside @ Infirmary Street. Tickets are available for purchase here.

Image courtesy of Louise Anderbjörk, provided to The Student as press material.