Uncensoring the censored: Films that expose

Did we lose the ability to form an opinion?  The constant fear of saying the wrong thing has turned our generation into one of self-censorship. Self-censorship is arguably the most dangerous kind, because it hides behind the facade of freedom. Nobody is telling us to stay quiet, which is why it’s so easy to miss. But we’re not the first people to learn how to hold things back and films show us this is universal.

In Jojo Rabbit, written and directed by Taika Waititi, Jojo doesn’t need anyone to silence him, because he already believes everything he’s been told. He’s ten, he’s in the Hitler Youth, and his best friend is an imaginary version of Hitler who agrees with him on everything. His life has no friction, what he does, and believes is accepted by his surroundings and his thoughts. Although it’s played for comedy, Jojo has never had a reason to doubt what he’s been taught, so he doesn’t know there’s anything missing.

That’s what the book-burning rally shows. Censorship isn’t only about what gets taken away but what gets put in its place. As the books burn, Jojo feels a sense of belonging in the cheers and joy of the others, through his childish perspective this is normal, censorship is tied to celebration, anything else would feel unnatural.

Elsa changes this, she’s the first person to push back on anything he believes, creating the friction his life’s been missing. He finds it uncomfortable, but it’s what makes him start questioning the environment he has been conditioned in. Jojo Rabbit is an extreme example, but it highlights how censorship hides in the small conveniences we don’t notice.

In Persepolis, written and co-directed by Marjane Satrapi, the autobiographical character of  Marjane learns early that there’s a distinction between who you are inside and who you are outside. At home she’s loud, opinionated, and punk. Outside she is controlled, quiet, and covered. Her freedoms disappear bit by bit, so each change feels like another normal day. Everything she once considered normal is now deemed immoral in the eyes of the state. She isn’t only told what to do, but she learns to police herself, which is self-censorship in its purest form. The music ban and tape smuggling scene exacerbates this idea, showing how Marjane due to her parents liberal beliefs knew there was something other than her current reality. Closer to home, the recent banning of Sally Rooney’s books in the UK, because of the author’s vocal support of Palestine Action, highlights how censorship of the media is a prevalent issue everywhere. Both Persepolis and Jojo Rabbit films  show that silence rarely arrives all at once, but rather it settles through habits before it is enforced.

So to answer the question I posed, it’s possible we gave up the ability to form our opinions, a little at a time as a convenience. Getting it back doesn’t take a revolution but rather noticing what we’re being shown, and what’s missing while asking who decided that and being willing to sit with the discomfort of an idea that we disagree with.

Photo by Egor Komarov on Unsplash