A short history of tuition fees in Scotland

In 2011, then-First Minister Alex Salmond famously quoted a line from Robert Burns promising that “the rocks will melt with the sun” before the Scottish National Party (SNP) would reintroduce tuition fees for Scottish students.

Over a decade later, the party still echoes this pledge, with current Scottish Education Secretary Jenny Gilruth recently emphasising the government’s commitment to free higher education.

In response to the questions about the financial struggles facing universities, Gilruth vowed that the SNP will not reintroduce tuition fees in Scotland.

Following devolution, the Labour-Liberal Democrat coalition government focused on reform of education policy.

In 2000, the Cubie report recommended replacing tuition fees with a graduate endowment scheme. This scheme was scrapped by the SNP minority government upon their entrance to power through the Graduate Endowment Abolition (Scotland) Bill in 2007. Since then, tuition has remained free for home-domiciled undergraduate students.

Eligibility for home tuition fees is determined by the Student Awards Agency Scotland (SAAS), and is based on a student’s nationality and place of residence. In 2023-2024, the Scottish government provided universities with £7,160 per home-domicile student, alongside an additional £1,820 covered through SAAS for tuition costs each year.

The SAAS payment has been frozen since 2011.

However, increasing costs and financial pressures on educational institutions have raised concerns regarding the financial deficit between the Scottish government’s per-student funding amount and the actual cost of teaching.

Critics argue that the SNP’s rejection of calls to reintroduce tuition fees is untenable. Alison Payne, research director of the Reform Scotland think tank argued that the current funding model is “unfair and unsustainable.”

Similarly, Scottish Conservative education spokesperson Miles Briggs accused Gilruth of a “lack of accountability” in addressing the financial pressures facing universities.

A central issue surrounding the debate on free tuition is its impact on university admissions.

Critics argue that institutions are forced to prioritise fee-paying students, in order to maintain their finances.

The Scottish Funding Council (SFC) enforces a cap on the number of university places available for Scottish students at each institution, limiting access to higher education. Some argue that this restriction is disproportionately damaging to students who benefit from widening access schemes.

As financial crises mount on universities across the UK, questions remain regarding existing funding models and the sustainability of the status quo.

Image is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 2.0 Generic license.