Review: A Midsummer Night’s Dream by The Shakespeare Troupe, St Andrews

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Stepping through the gates of the St Andrews’ Royal Botanic Gardens in the harsh November breeze, my expectations for The Shakespeare Troupe’s production of A Midsummer Night’s Dream were not high. As I sat down on the bare grass, soiling my overcoat, I felt completely baffled by the concept of producing any show in this weather. I have never been so glad to have been proven wrong.

From the moment the flute began to play, arranged by Cyrus Tahbaz, I felt transported to a completely new space, the wind no longer biting and one focus remained: the unravelling of Shakespeare’s words. This outdoor performance truly added a sense of the ethereal, perfectly accompanying the actors cycling in and out of scenes.

James Carder-Geddes provided wonderful direction to the show, injecting a sense of dry and witty humour into the comedic and dramatic plot, which was made outstanding by the work of Isaac Thompson-Gibbs as Nick Bottom. In this role, he pushed the limits of the character’s melodrama, putting a Blackadder-esque spin on it, and demonstrating talent that could later see him on the stage with the RSC. This was seen progressing into the plot between the four lovers of Hermia, Helena, Lysander and Demetrius (Margo Anderson, Gabriella Kalayamotho, Harry Aspinall and Rupert Carter), who all have wonderful chemistry with one another, and played genuinely heartfelt versions of Shakespeare’s original characters. Their performances operated in brilliant harmony with one another, with the action between the four culminating in a raucous climax in Act 3. It was clear to see, as Anderson and Kalayamotho wrestled and toppled one another, the joy that had been put into creating this show, and the actors’ great creativity.

However, despite these wonderful characterisations, the show was held back somewhat by the inclusion of forced humour, particularly in the physical comedy of the other Mechanicals, which attempted to impose laughter, as opposed to just letting the delivery of Shakespeare’s words speak for themself. These outdated and somewhat cringe-worthy additions often clashed with the the plot. Unfortunately, this seemed to be most prevalent in the character of Puck, portrayed by Jonathan Brown, whose performance and discourse with other characters seemed to drag the audience away from the plot, rather than confronting it head on. Despite the good natured and downright jolly performance, the prominence of this humour leaves some aspects of the play jarring— creating disjunction between the plot of the lovers and the fairies, for which Puck is often the link between.

In spite of this, I must admit this show was an absolute hit for audiences, and the ambition of the staging (especially in light of weather circumstances on a cold November’s weekend), performances, and music, leave something considerable to be admired by all.

Image provided for The Student by The Shakespeare Troupe as press material.