“Careless and not deliberate” is the slogan drifting between every news outlet worth reading. Nadhim Zahawi, chairman of the Conservative Party, is under fire for mishandling his tax affairs. After allegedly mismanaging shares of his company YouGov, Zahawi agreed to pay nearly five million pounds to HMRC as a settlement, including a 30% penalty. This settlement, he thought, would allow him to leave this upset in the past and focus on public service.
It seems fair: everyone at some point has made a minor clerical error. A rounding issue. A misplaced decimal, perhaps. HMRC has accepted the settlement and Zahawi has apologised. So that’s where the issue should be left. Surely we should take his word for it. After all, honesty has been a central policy for the Tories in recent years.
Or, alternatively, Nadhim Zahawi’s “murky affair” (as Labour’s chairwoman puts it) has been subject to the same calculated smudging of the facts that the British public has grown so used to. Perhaps this is less an honest mistake than the use of intentional vagueness. Obscure a subject for long enough and the media cycle will eventually move on to the newest scandal.
Zahawi’s slow arrival at the truth was not some momentary attack of amnesia, it was strategy. He has curated and revealed a perfectly insufficient amount of information, in the hope that his misdemeanours will be forgotten. His recent statement lacks this vagueness, and instead seems to translate roughly to “shit, you caught me”.
It is important to remember that Zahawi has already survived plenty of controversy. As a veteran of both Johnson and Truss cabinets and their respective catastrophes, Zahawi has been one of few to emerge relatively unscathed. This time is different. The focus rests solely upon Zahawi as the opposite side of the house clamours for his departure. As several political correspondents have noted, the role of the chairman is to calm the media flurry around controversies, not to spark new ones.
Somehow, tax evasion doesn’t gel with the PM’s newly outlined promises for “integrity, professionalism and accountability”. Zahawi’s tax avoidance scandal falls alongside accusations aimed at the chairman of the BBC and the criticism levied towards PM Rishi Sunak over his wife’s non-dom status.
The pressure on Sunak is mounting. Again. As Angela Rayner puts it, this settlement signifies “a potential conflict of interest at the heart of government”. Rishi Sunak has done his best to cultivate an image of stability, but can the Tories endure yet another optical nightmare? If the polling is any indicator, probably not. Attempting to douse the flames, Rishi has called for Sir Laurie Magnus to examine the issue further, in a last-ditch display of transparency.
Independent ethics investigation or not, Nadhim Zahawi’s political career teeters at the edge of a precipice. Maybe, like his previous bosses, he will cling to the windowsills of the Commons for a few more weeks. But, as one former conservative minister puts it, he seems categorically “screwed” (Wright and Pickard, The Telegraph).
“Prime Minister Rishi Sunak meets Minister Nadhim Zahawi. (52452989277)” by UK Government is licensed under CC BY 2.0.
Related
The End of Nadhim Zahawi?
“Careless and not deliberate” is the slogan drifting between every news outlet worth reading. Nadhim Zahawi, chairman of the Conservative Party, is under fire for mishandling his tax affairs. After allegedly mismanaging shares of his company YouGov, Zahawi agreed to pay nearly five million pounds to HMRC as a settlement, including a 30% penalty. This settlement, he thought, would allow him to leave this upset in the past and focus on public service.
It seems fair: everyone at some point has made a minor clerical error. A rounding issue. A misplaced decimal, perhaps. HMRC has accepted the settlement and Zahawi has apologised. So that’s where the issue should be left. Surely we should take his word for it. After all, honesty has been a central policy for the Tories in recent years.
Or, alternatively, Nadhim Zahawi’s “murky affair” (as Labour’s chairwoman puts it) has been subject to the same calculated smudging of the facts that the British public has grown so used to. Perhaps this is less an honest mistake than the use of intentional vagueness. Obscure a subject for long enough and the media cycle will eventually move on to the newest scandal.
Zahawi’s slow arrival at the truth was not some momentary attack of amnesia, it was strategy. He has curated and revealed a perfectly insufficient amount of information, in the hope that his misdemeanours will be forgotten. His recent statement lacks this vagueness, and instead seems to translate roughly to “shit, you caught me”.
It is important to remember that Zahawi has already survived plenty of controversy. As a veteran of both Johnson and Truss cabinets and their respective catastrophes, Zahawi has been one of few to emerge relatively unscathed. This time is different. The focus rests solely upon Zahawi as the opposite side of the house clamours for his departure. As several political correspondents have noted, the role of the chairman is to calm the media flurry around controversies, not to spark new ones.
Somehow, tax evasion doesn’t gel with the PM’s newly outlined promises for “integrity, professionalism and accountability”. Zahawi’s tax avoidance scandal falls alongside accusations aimed at the chairman of the BBC and the criticism levied towards PM Rishi Sunak over his wife’s non-dom status.
The pressure on Sunak is mounting. Again. As Angela Rayner puts it, this settlement signifies “a potential conflict of interest at the heart of government”. Rishi Sunak has done his best to cultivate an image of stability, but can the Tories endure yet another optical nightmare? If the polling is any indicator, probably not. Attempting to douse the flames, Rishi has called for Sir Laurie Magnus to examine the issue further, in a last-ditch display of transparency.
Independent ethics investigation or not, Nadhim Zahawi’s political career teeters at the edge of a precipice. Maybe, like his previous bosses, he will cling to the windowsills of the Commons for a few more weeks. But, as one former conservative minister puts it, he seems categorically “screwed” (Wright and Pickard, The Telegraph).
“Prime Minister Rishi Sunak meets Minister Nadhim Zahawi. (52452989277)” by UK Government is licensed under CC BY 2.0.
Share this:
Like this:
Related