Think of the worst dinner party you’ve ever been to, and multiply it by twenty. Such is the
atmosphere of Dinner by Moira Buffini. This meeting of the worst people you’ve ever seen is
the subject of Exeter University Theatre Company’s (EUTC) 2024 Fringe performance.
Leading the dinner party is a melodramatic, whimpering housewife Paige and her self-help
philosopher husband Lars. They’re joined by their microbiologist friend Hal his new newscaster wife Siân. (It’s unclear why either of these couples ever married, because they seem to hate each other and have nothing in common aside from being insufferable). They’re joined by Lars’ artsy-fartsy friend Wynne and a mysterious gatecrasher named Mike. Presiding over the whole affair is a mysterious, silent, unnamed waiter. The evening descends into bickering, drama, and finally death.
As far as the source material goes, I largely agree Michael Billington’s 2002 review of Dinner’s original West End run: “Buffini has little to tell us other than that these are sad, unhappy people whose final motive is one of crude self-preservation.” These characters are simple creatures with simple motives. Dinner just isn’t quite the political statement it tries to be. Yes, rich people are small-minded and boring and miserable. Yes, they suck. … Is that all?
Despite this, the students behind the production work with what they’ve got. Isabella Maunder is delightfully wicked as Paige and Charlie Holland plays a perfectly tone-deaf Wynne. Special praise must be reserved for Dylan Sweet as the Waiter. Where other actors in this cast opt for to go louder, angrier, more dramatic to make their point, Sweet stays magnetically silent. His charisma stands out among the crowded dinner table.
There are other growing pains here. The script has been cut nearly in half (from 90 minutes to 50) in order to meet the requirements of the Fringe. Certain plot points never come to fruition or simply don’t make sense; characters angrily fall out and then make up with little explanation. When I learned that the play was originally twice as long, these plot holes suddenly became understandable.
Dinner is clearly meant to take place on a stage, where the cast can interact with freedom of movement, but the venue of a tiny hotel conference room doesn’t allow it. The stage design involving a massive dinner table and seats on three sides leaves nearly half the audience with an obstructed view, and consequently I spent significant portions of Dinner staring at the back of heads. I wonder if executive decisions could have been made earlier in the process – like selecting a shorter script or a play with Fringe-friendly stage design – which would have provided everyone involved in the production the space they needed to shine.
All in all, Dinner is funny and sharp if sometimes predictable. The cast demonstrates talent and has fun with their material. Audiences will feel transported to the chaotic, dizzying mess of a dinner party hellscape. The question is whether they should have been there in the first place.
Dinner is on at 17:35 in The Space on the Mile (Space 1) until 24 August.
Buy tickets here.
Images provided by the Exeter University Theatre Company






