Why do we root for the Traitors?

Well, there we have it! The second season of  Celebrity Traitors has come and gone ending in an extremely unexpected, last-minute Faithful win, with players Romesh Ranganathan and Sebastian Croft coming out on top. Now, whilst these two were admittedly two of my personal favourite individual players throughout the series, I couldn’t help feeling slightly disappointed at the Traitors’ loss. And it seems I’m not alone in feeling this; many viewers have come onto social media to express this exact sentiment.

This highlights quite an interesting conundrum: why do we even root for the Traitors in the first place considering the deceptive and manipulative nature of the role? It’s in the name, people! For the duration of the show, these players must manipulate their peers, plant seeds of doubt in the heads of their closest friends, they must murder them and then go on to play dumb at breakfast.

It comes down to our position as the audience. The Traitors are the most central part of the narrative, with the Faithfuls’ main purpose being to hunt them down, meaning that they will inevitably get significantly more screentime than the majority of players. We, as viewers, get so many more opportunities to root for them simply because we see and hear their perspectives the most in the show’s editing. It also makes sense then why — year after year — viewers find themselves frustrated with the Faithfuls for their endless paranoia, blunders and seemingly nonsensical theories while they stumble in the dark.

It’s also interesting to note another aspect of this editing bias; that many Faithfuls do strategise and plan ahead in their own time but that this is left off-screen. Both Hannah Fry and Joe Lycett have described the notebooks they kept at their accommodation to plan ahead and try to suss out who the Traitors were. Now, whilst it is understandable that viewers won’t see every instance of Traitor-hunting, especially whilst out-of-hours, this does expose how much more audiences are aligned with the Traitors given that we do get to see them gather in the turret and plan ahead.

In this season specifically, we saw so many switches in the Traitors, including two notably faulty recruitments, that very clearly laid out this narrative that the Traitors had gone through many trials and tribulations together and would eventually succeed. By the penultimate episode, the Traitors took up nearly half of the entire remaining cast and, even with James Acaster’s exit, they seemed strong enough to pull through. In fact, Maya and Kenny had somehow managed to last through the show with barely any suspicion (as far as we saw) and had a strong sense of teamwork that felt akin to the dynamic of winning traitors Rachel Duffy and Stephen Libby. Both pairs had proven time and time again how committed they were to each other in their gameplay, with Libby resisting the urge to betray his co-Traitor in the series finale. It’s this added layer of camaraderie within the Traitors, on top of the audience’s alignment with them that tends to cement them as worthy of our support.

So, while I know many people that frequently root for the Faithful for goodness’ sake, I will continue to be an avid Traitor-supporter and hope for a Traitor-triumph in the upcoming civilian season in the new year.

Illustration by Tracy Ratliff @paisley_pen_creative