Album Review: Angel by Lizzy McAlpine

Rating: 4 out of 5.

“I sing for myself, I am a better friend, You sound like yourself again.” Lizzy McAlpine’s fourth studio album Angel delves into a confessional, vulnerable depiction of McAlpine’s understanding of friendship, love, grief, and herself as an artist.

Approximately two years after her previous release, Older, Lizzy McAlpine returns to the music scene following her Broadway debut in the production of Floyd Collins in 2025 as Nellie Collins. McAlpine wrote this album before, during, and after performing on Broadway, while also navigating the shifting stages of a relationship. These experiences shape the lyrics, from tender love songs like ‘Mason’s song’ to ‘Soldier of the road,’ which directly references the truths of working in the music industry, and ‘The crowd,’ a vulnerable ballad dedicated to her late father and how she longs to make him proud. The lead single ‘The light in the painting,’ is a clear declaration of love in the form of a soothing melody and delicate lyrics, setting off the romantic and gentle tone that the album holds throughout all 14 tracks.

This album differs from her past productions, straying away from the pop-like elements that defined her earlier works. Angel is mostly built around tender pianos and soft guitars, shifting towards a more traditional folk sound. Clearly inspired by Joni Mitchell’s melodic lilting and the 70s Laurel Canyon scene, McAlpine still represents the 21st-century indie-folk identity. True to its title, Angel’s tracks cohesively create a serene atmosphere that embraces the listener, letting the songs establish a cinematic and tangible feeling, allowing the listener to empathise with greater depth.

What stands out most on this record is McAlpine’s songwriting. As a true singer-songwriter, she effortlessly shifts from themes of hopeful intimacy of falling in love to isolating heartbreak; from the unwavering endurance of relationships through distance to the unsettling persistence of grief. She also turns the lens toward toxic past relationships, documenting the very real compulsion of longing for people who are not good for her, exposing the friction between knowing better and feeling worse. Her ability to intertwine the promising blooming of a new relationship with the decline of another, without losing the sonic harmoniousness of peace, makes this album remarkable.

The central spirit of love and contentment is what distinguishes this album from her past releases. While her past projects are characterised by tension and conflict, this album’s theme is one of inner peace and resolution, which may make it feel static or simplistic. The sonic coherence that some praise is what others find one-dimensional and homogeneous. Nevertheless, this shift towards tranquillity is where Angel finds its strength; rather than flattening her sound, this subtle confidence offers a compelling shift in her artistic identity.

Overall, while this album is still consistent with Lizzy McAlpine’s discography, Angel puts an emphasis on self-discovery that evokes freedom rather than emotional devastation. Ultimately, the record showcases an artist who chooses to stop using her pain as a stage and who embraces hard-won clarity and the bitter truth, resulting in a peace that no longer requires tearing herself apart.

“McAlpine in 2026” by Moonisangel is licensed under CC0.