Sophie Swithinbank’s play Bacon took Edinburgh Fringe by storm last year and left audiences reeling with Swithinbank’s marvellous and masterful storytelling. This year, she returns with Surrender, a collaboration with Phoebe Ladenberg who acts as the one-woman performer in this marvel of a play.
It’s a simple set, only a chair with three hooks and two coats hanging as the backdrop, but the simplicity ends there, as a story of motherhood full of twists and turns unravels, told by a narrator who you never quite trust but empathise with all the same. Ladenberg’s performance as Mother is toe-curling. Her ability to shift between scenes and timelines, sometimes real and sometimes not real, is an art form all its own. You can’t help but weep with her as the severity of her actions leads her to her own demise, but even that is not a fair assessment of the character’s complexities.
Trapped not only in her lessening sense of reality, but also in a societal structure that offers minimal support to single parents and a thriving stigmatism against mothers experiencing mental health crises, it’s hard to decipher your own feelings towards a mother whose neglect you can’t recognize. In classic Swithinbank style, you’re left questioning every one of your own beliefs, biases and feelings that reared its head over the course of the hour. The direction by Nancy Medina is tightly crafted with lightening precision as the play navigates multiple dimensions. The combination of Medina, Swithinbank and Ladenberg’s artistry is a spectacular and certainly not to be overlooked amongst the many one people shows at this year’s festival. I suspect I will spend many years untangling the questions this piece has planted in my head.
Image by Alan Harford provided by Summerhall Press Release.





