Whether it be discussions about Britain restoring its ‘lost power’, or making America great again, the rising political right has been using a sentimental nostalgia of a distant (perhaps non-existent, or overly-romanticised) past to promote its anti-liberal ideas and ideologies. Some people have discussed nostalgia as the force currently ruining politics, making it polarised and threatening our social progress. Nonetheless, I think the very fact that these right-wing ideas are becoming increasingly influential and popular indicates that the dissatisfactions driving them have a substance which should be recognised, and responded to, rather than dismissed as a shallow ‘nostalgia’.
Considering that we currently live in a liberal international order, it feels as though many liberal politicians believe that their status quo is so obviously correct and deserved, that any other options contesting it can be simply dismissed. In responding to the more recent shift towards the radical right’s ’past-oriented’ vision, a common tactic of theirs seems to be to just mock and push away any right-wing supporters, classifying their feelings and political opinions as ‘silly’ or ‘stupid’. While I don’t agree with any ideological aspects of the political right, I can recognise that all this does is feed into the victim-narratives of the radical right, and strengthens people’s attachment to their regressive ideas, further polarising the political scene.
I think the most obvious example of this is the current state of US politics. The Democrats lost to Trump in the 2016 and 2024 US elections because they dismissed his statements and supporters as unserious. They continually underestimate Trump’s political force, and thus don’t actually do anything sufficiently substantial to mobilise their own electoral base, much of which is also dissatisfied with the US establishment and its systems.
We can’t simply write off every single person convinced by the statements of right-wing politicians as just being manipulated by radical, conservative ideas. Because while the Right is manipulating people’s dissatisfactions by simplifying their causes, and promoting a ‘better past’ to push its exclusionary agenda, it wouldn’t be able to do so at such alarming success rates if not for the unresolved systemic issues causing people to be frustrated at the status quo in the first place.
It’s not necessarily that all of liberalism is wrong, or unfixable, but political pluralism and collaborative discussion is precisely what moves politics forward. Instead, liberal politicians are feeding into the polarisation tactics of the Right by playing party politics, rather than trying to implement economically and socially progressive reforms that would make people feel less angry and disenchanted with liberal democracy.
Nostalgia does not have to be backwards and dangerous. When not overly-romanticised, but examined, there are aspects of the past that can be incorporated into an aspirational, progressive vision for the world. While it can make us misremember or idealise old structures, and be exploited to promote regressive and exclusionary ideas, it can also motivate us to improve the systems put in place in the present, when intelligently considered. Right-wing ideas don’t need to be mocked and dismissed; they need to be appropriately refuted, but also discussed.
“Make America Great Again hat” by Gage Skidmore is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.
Related
We Cannot Dismiss the Shift Towards Nostalgia Politics
Whether it be discussions about Britain restoring its ‘lost power’, or making America great again, the rising political right has been using a sentimental nostalgia of a distant (perhaps non-existent, or overly-romanticised) past to promote its anti-liberal ideas and ideologies. Some people have discussed nostalgia as the force currently ruining politics, making it polarised and threatening our social progress. Nonetheless, I think the very fact that these right-wing ideas are becoming increasingly influential and popular indicates that the dissatisfactions driving them have a substance which should be recognised, and responded to, rather than dismissed as a shallow ‘nostalgia’.
Considering that we currently live in a liberal international order, it feels as though many liberal politicians believe that their status quo is so obviously correct and deserved, that any other options contesting it can be simply dismissed. In responding to the more recent shift towards the radical right’s ’past-oriented’ vision, a common tactic of theirs seems to be to just mock and push away any right-wing supporters, classifying their feelings and political opinions as ‘silly’ or ‘stupid’. While I don’t agree with any ideological aspects of the political right, I can recognise that all this does is feed into the victim-narratives of the radical right, and strengthens people’s attachment to their regressive ideas, further polarising the political scene.
I think the most obvious example of this is the current state of US politics. The Democrats lost to Trump in the 2016 and 2024 US elections because they dismissed his statements and supporters as unserious. They continually underestimate Trump’s political force, and thus don’t actually do anything sufficiently substantial to mobilise their own electoral base, much of which is also dissatisfied with the US establishment and its systems.
We can’t simply write off every single person convinced by the statements of right-wing politicians as just being manipulated by radical, conservative ideas. Because while the Right is manipulating people’s dissatisfactions by simplifying their causes, and promoting a ‘better past’ to push its exclusionary agenda, it wouldn’t be able to do so at such alarming success rates if not for the unresolved systemic issues causing people to be frustrated at the status quo in the first place.
It’s not necessarily that all of liberalism is wrong, or unfixable, but political pluralism and collaborative discussion is precisely what moves politics forward. Instead, liberal politicians are feeding into the polarisation tactics of the Right by playing party politics, rather than trying to implement economically and socially progressive reforms that would make people feel less angry and disenchanted with liberal democracy.
Nostalgia does not have to be backwards and dangerous. When not overly-romanticised, but examined, there are aspects of the past that can be incorporated into an aspirational, progressive vision for the world. While it can make us misremember or idealise old structures, and be exploited to promote regressive and exclusionary ideas, it can also motivate us to improve the systems put in place in the present, when intelligently considered. Right-wing ideas don’t need to be mocked and dismissed; they need to be appropriately refuted, but also discussed.
“Make America Great Again hat” by Gage Skidmore is licensed under CC BY-SA 2.0.
Share this:
Like this:
Related