Based upon the book De Oönskade by Rasmus Lindgren, Jonatan Etzler’s Bad Apples follows an idealistic British primary school teacher (Saoirse Ronan) who kidnaps a troublesome pupil in pursuit of a more peaceful class.
The black comedy creates moments of genuine tension and absurdity, however its satire is ultimately too blunt to fully land. From the first image of literal bad apples being processed in a mill, the film sacrifices subtlety in favour of heavy handedness.
In my opinion, Chris Roe’s score epitomises this — similar dark comedies such as The Drama are notable for their mischievous and focused music, however Roe’s selection creates a cartoonish atmosphere which fails to ground the plot.
While Ronan provides a stellar performance, the film (perhaps curtailed by its school setting) rarely matches her intensity, with anxiety giving way to stagnancy as the pace flattens. The ending compounds this, withholding a final cataclysmic push, which could’ve resulted in a truly memorable film. The absurdities of the plot are never sufficiently justified, leaving viewers distracted by practical questions rather than absorbed in the (sometimes confused) satire.
Ultimately, though sharply comedic in some scenes and an accurate portrayal of the horrors of Ofsted, Bad Apples fails to create the solid plot foundation on which its darker ideas can truly be explored.





