Review: Practical Magic 2

Rating: 2 out of 5.

As witchy season begins to haunt the air we are gifted with another cheap trick to appease nostalgia-seeking millennials. Practical Magic 2 has taken the magical story of love and sisterhood of its predecessor and presented a lacklustre sequel.

The story follows Sally (Sandra Bullock) and Gillian Owens (Nicole Kidman) as they travel to London to save Sally’s daughter (Joey King), from using dark magic. While this might seem like a simple story, there is also an array of embedded sub-plots which muddle the action significantly. ‘Bigger is better’ was not the move for this film, giving us more than even they themselves could handle. The most disappointing part of the film for me was a lack in the representation of sisterly love — the driving force in the first film. Sally has another daughter in the film played by Maisie Williams, who is almost completely forgotten, playing no significant role in the film at all. Not only did they underuse an incredible actor, but lost the original emotional pull of the first film. 

The story was also incapable of extracting any genuine emotions, and the sadder scenes felt like they were added just for the sake of it. I felt like I was being tricked to respond in ways the film simply did not warrant. 

The performances were fine, even when Kidman forgot she was playing an American. The English set was hilariously disjointed, with ancient buses and trains taking them around modern England. While the costumes were whimsical on occasion, some characters’ outfits were simply an eyesore. 

Overall, the film has some major flaws which are all disappointing to see. Our 2026 polished film techniques, and questionable fashion choices did not serve the witches we know and love well.

Photo by Devin H on Unsplash